General Forums >> The Anonymous Zone >> What anti-depressant for PMT??
What anti-depressant for PMT??
|
Anonymous back to top |
Posted over 2 years ago Hi. I suffer with awful PMT and my GP recommended an AD to help with the way I feel prior to my period. I feel really low two weeks before my period, get really sore boobs, bloated stomach and generally feel really low. I have tried other treatment such as reflexology, st john's wort, meditation, exercise and yet nothing seems to be working. I only feel 'normal' for two weeks of the month. What would be the best treatment for this? I also suffer with mild anxiety and on occasion panic attacks. She mentioned Citalopram. Anyone know much about this medication? Thanks in advance. |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Have you tried going on the combined pill? That can certainly help. Citalopram is a mild antidepressant that is effective against anxiety which is why I take it at the moment and I have found that it has helped me a great deal. I don't know how it would affect your PMS though I'm afraid but I can recomend it for reducing anxious feelings but not anxious thoughts. Feel free to get in touch if you have any specific questions as it's a big decision to put mind altering chemicals into your body but I feel it was the right choice for me :-) |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago you cannot take st johns wort with a prescribed anti-depressant. be careful. |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago This is confusing. Citalopram is a Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor (SSRI). This means that it targets the neurotransmitter, serotonin. It works by building up serotonin levels gradually over several weeks. I'm no expert in PMS but I'd have thought that the issue is hormonal rather than serotonin based. I'd also have thought that it's a short-lived recurring problem rather than the chronic sort of disorder that SSRIs are designed to treat. Surely the normal serotonin production for the Central Nervous System would simply adjust to accommodate the prescription anyway - thus negating any short-term effects in acute PMS. What's the rationale for this - or is it just the same desperation-induced prescribing that results in so many anti-depressant prescriptions? If there is a proper medical rationale for this suggestion what is it? Does anyone know? I'd genuinely love to know how a long-term SSRI can help acute PMS. Bear in mind that short-term SSRIs are pretty pointless. Cheers, Stuart |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago I too am confused. I'm not sure that starting on citalopram would be good idea without first trying varying forms of contraceptive pill to try and balance out the hormones. I too am on citalopram for anxiety and yes it works but not easy to come off as I have been finding. Does your GP intend to place you on this indefinatly? As stuart says, this needs to build up in your system and wouldn't work if you took it on an ad hoc basis and I would advise you not too. Just seems a little extreme to me. Do you suffer with pain at this time as well/ other symptoms Also how often does your anxiety affect you... do you often have panic attacks? sorry not being nosey just seeing if the GP is trying to kill two birds with one stone maybe... |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Anonymous says ...
Or maybe they've fallen into the trap of believing that they have to come up with a solution of some sort. A lot of doctors get caught in that trap. They think that medicine has to have the answer when often it's not there - so they clutch at straws instead. It seems to spring from the cultural notion that doctors are suposed to know best when often they're just as helpless as the rest of us. As I said - if there is a real rationale (as opposed to clutching at straws) I'd love to hear it. Cheers, Stuart |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Hello, I used to suffer terribly with PMT and anxiety/panic attacks. I was a real nightmare to live with and i like you only really felt normal about 2 weeks in four. I was prescribed antidepressants as i was really low - Prozac. However after taking these for a few months i gained a stone in weight. The doctor said i shouldnt worry about the weight if i felt happy. Obviously i wasnt happy about the gain in weight so i felt more down. I was also suffering from chronic period pains every month. A friend suggested the "coil" as she said she had no periods at all. To cut a long story short a did get the "Mirena Coil" and ive never looked back. I rarely have any periods or pains now. My PMT also seems to have disappeared. It really did work for me and i cant recommend it enough. I know what you are going through belive me you are not on your own. Best wishes Julesx |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Personally I wouldn't take ADs for PMT, they have horrendous side effects and as Stuart says the rationale doesn't sound justified. |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Anonymous says ...
|
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Hi, I just wanted to explain from a different perspective that the Anxiety and PMS are all symptoms of some feelings that haven't been dealt with. As a Nurse and Hypnotherapist I feel that i can look at things from both points of view. Treating the symptoms of Anxiety and PMS are all well and good but it doesn't get rid of the causes of it and doesn't help you to gain your self esteem, confidence and control back over your life. I am not in anyway anti medication. There are many wayd of treating anxiety - did you know that anxiety is heightened by lack of sleep? when we become anxious our gut shuts down adnwe don't absorb enough Vit B? (which in turn can lead to tiredness) I suggest you seek the help of a trained counsellor, CBT or Hypnotherapy practitioner who can work with you to discover the real reasons behind your symptoms together then you will be able to change your life for the better. I wish you the best of luck on your journey Karen
|
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Hi Karen. As a sufferer of PMS and anxiety, my GP also recommended anti-d's which did seem to help but I couldn't stick the side effects so came off them. Anyway, I suggested CBT and she said "there is a long waiting list, plus it is too expensive" so never did refer me. I'm certainly not in a postition to pay for the treatment myself. I agree, the causes of PMS and/or anxiety could be due to feelings that haven't been dealt with, as the PMS and later the anxiety appeared after some trauma in my life. Not sure where to go from here as most GP's seem to presribe anti-d's as a quick fix and their cheaper than therapy. |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Hi, I am sorry to hear that the waiting list is so long for CBT but Hypnotherapy can be a lot quickerand usually costs around £45 per session with you need ing approximately 6-10 sessions. I personally offer flexible payment options for those who find difficulty in paying each week. Some therapists are registered with the LHB and have NHS provider numbers - depending on your GP they may consider a referral through the NHS which may mean you would only part fund or not pay. If you would like help to find a reputable therapist in your area let me know and i will find someone who specialises in trauma. There are some things you can do to minimise your anxiety: take a vit b complex supplement (with permission from GP) consider a short course of Magnesium supplement for no more than 6 weeks (nature's tranquiliser!!). Sleep!!!!! or rest asmuch as you are able. Visit Emofree.com for free downloadable EFT instructions ( I am giving away busiiness here lol) to help you to reduce the emotions attached to certain events in your life ( we normally have over 200 each - so get tapping!!) Be kind to yourself!!! we usually feel ill because it tells us physically to slow down, due mainly because we've ignored our mind that has been telling us for weeks we need a rest but we've ignored it!! you can E-mail me personally if you want a proper chat on info@easytherapies.co.uk |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago oh and I forgot if youwork for a health trust you should have access to a staff counsellor - free and a shorter waiting list!!! |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Anonymous says ...
|
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Somebody mentioned magnesium (and Vit B) earlier on... I don't suffer (terribly) from moodswings but suffer from terrible period pains. Or used to, at least. A friend suggested magnesium supplement with calcium (don't know why both) and raspberry leaf tea. I was suspicious but decided to try them anyway. It's only been a couple of months but I've felt SOO much better. No longer needs loads of painkillers and my machine, neither do I need to crawl under the duvet for a day or two. GP suggested going on the pill but I figured I could try supplements first. Never thought they would help.. shocker :) |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Meant to say my TENS machine, in the post above |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Anonymous says ...
That's really interesting and a completely new one on me - thanks for the info. I wonder if you have any references for this research. I'd be really interested to follow this up. I'll tell you why - it's because the use of SSRIs in this sort of situation in people not otherwise showing depressive symptoms would be contraindicated according to the training I received. If that's changed and the licensing conditions of SSRI's have changed I'd be fascinated to know what's brought that change about. If you do have any references I'd be especially grateful if you could send me some links to independent research (not simply that conducted by pharmacological companies out to make a sale) although I appreciate that often pharmaceutical company research is all that's available. Do you know if NICE have expressed an opinion on this? Fascinating. Cheers, Stuart
|
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Anonymous says ...
also - could you let me have the reference for the quote above about much enthusiasm etc please? Cheers, Stuart |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Anonymous says ...
No Stuart, many GP's do NOT prescribe anti depressants willy nilly. They do make sure that the patient requires them and offers them councelling as well. The GP's won't do anything that will affect their budget. I was prescribed a 60mg tablet but was told I would have to take 3X 20mg as it would cost the GP sugery £102 more to give me one tablet so, I have to take 3!! |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago Anonymous says ...
You're absolutely right - many GPs are much better than that - but many are not. That's why I asked the question. I am genuinely interested in the rationale for this, if there is one (aside from just cost). That's why I've asked for the research references and to know what the quotation was about/where it was from Cheers, Stuart.
|
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago To the person who posted the research stuff on SSRIs and PMT: Please let us have the reference of the journal or book you typed it from or failing that the weblink to wherever it was cut and pasted from. I'm really not trying to be funny - I'm genuinely keen to follow this up because it's something I didn't know about and I think I really should try to understand it better. Cheers, Stuart |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted over 2 years ago It's OK - I found it: http://www.tiscali.co.uk/lifestyle/healthfitness/health_advice/netdoctor/000178.html Unfortunately it's not referenced either. Still an interesting proposition though. Ho hum. I'll add it to the list of things to google when time allows. Cheers, Stuart
|
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted about 1 year ago Anonymous says ...
The syndrome is made up of a collection of more than 150 different symptoms and is experienced by around 90% of women at some point in their reproductive lives.A good diet accompanied by vitamin/mineral supplements, a good B-complex would be a good one to pick up as well as calcium for moodiness, avoid the usual things like dairy and red meat if you can, limit soy as it tends to have bad effects on women's hormones, lots of vegetables and fruit, raw being best, at least a week prior to your symptoms normally start acting up – as always, lots of water is always a plus. Regards, |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted about 1 year ago Hello to all, I'm james from NY, I'm Newbie to this forum and I'm very happy to be here. I'm agree with above comment. Really there are around 90% of women at some point in their reproductive lives.A good diet accompanied by vitamin/mineral supplements, a good B-complex would be a good one to pick up as well as calcium for moodiness, avoid the usual things like dairy and red meat if you can, limit soy as it tends to have bad effects on women's hormones, lots of vegetables and fruit, raw being best. Thanks and Regards, James, NY |
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted about 1 year ago Anonymous says ...
|
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted about 1 year ago Anonymous says ...
|
|
Anonymous back to top |
| Posted about 1 year ago Hello, Very nice forum site.... I found good information here. You have really very awesome site. Thanks for sharing.... |
or is it just mood change?